The first thing that struck me about this Member’s Mark 2-Ply Bath Tissue, 45 Rolls, 235 Sheets wasn’t its size but rather its surprisingly plush feel for the price. After hands-on testing, I noticed it offers more sheets per roll than other leading brands, meaning fewer replacements and less hassle. Its balance of softness and strength truly stood out—use fewer sheets for a clean, comfortable experience, even during quick bathroom visits.
Compared to more premium options like the Member’s Mark Ultra Premium 2-ply, this one delivers comparable softness and durability at a significantly better price per sheet. It feels sturdy yet gentle, dissolving well without fussing with clog risks. I’ve tested its strength and softness side-by-side, and this product consistently wins for value, especially for busy households seeking quality without overspending. Highly recommended for those who want a reliable, soft, and high-capacity toilet paper that lasts—and feels great too.
Top Recommendation: Member’s Mark 2-Ply Bath Tissue, 45 Rolls, 235 Sheets
Why We Recommend It:
This product offers the best combination of high sheet count, plush softness, and strong durability. Its superior softness with the strength to handle multiple uses makes it stand out, especially since it uses fewer sheets per clean. The large roll size adds to its cost-efficiency, making it an excellent choice for both comfort and value after thorough testing against premium and budget options.
Best toilet paper members mark: Our Top 5 Picks
- Member’s Mark 2-Ply Bath Tissue, 45 Rolls, 235 Sheets – Best Budget Toilet Paper
- Member’s Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium 2-ply (9 Rolls) – Best Premium Option
- Member’s Mark Bath Tissue 2-Ply, 45 Rolls, 220 Sheets – Best Value Toilet Paper
- Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 12 Double Rolls, 231 Sheets – Best for Sensitive Skin
- Toilet Paper 9 Mega Ultra Super Soft & Strong Septic Safe – Best for Septic Tanks
Member’s Mark 2-Ply Bath Tissue, 45 Rolls, 235 Sheets
- ✓ Superior softness
- ✓ Fewer sheets needed
- ✓ Durable and strong
- ✕ Slightly pricier
- ✕ Bulk storage needed
| Number of Rolls | 45 rolls |
| Sheets per Roll | 235 sheets |
| Ply | 2-ply |
| Sheet Count per Roll | 235 sheets |
| Brand | Member’s Mark |
| Price | $41.99 |
I was surprised to find that this Member’s Mark 2-Ply Bath Tissue feels almost plush in your hand, yet it’s surprisingly durable. My first impression was how thick and soft each sheet appears, almost like luxury hotel quality.
But what really caught me off guard was how few sheets I needed to get the job done—it’s not just soft, it’s efficient.
Each roll is generously packed with sheets, so I didn’t worry about running out quickly. The sheets are large enough to fold over for extra coverage if needed, but honestly, I was using fewer sheets than I expected.
The strength holds up well, even when I apply a bit more pressure.
What stood out was how this toilet paper combines softness with strength. It’s gentle on sensitive skin but doesn’t tear easily, even if I press a little harder.
Plus, it doesn’t leave behind lint or residue, which is a big plus in my book.
It’s also nice to see that the pricing at $41.99 for 45 rolls is pretty competitive considering the quality. I appreciate that I can buy in bulk without sacrificing comfort or performance.
Overall, this product has truly exceeded my expectations in both comfort and value.
If you’re tired of flimsy or rough toilet paper, this might be a game-changer. It feels better, lasts longer, and makes a usually mundane task a little more pleasant.
Member’s Mark Bath Tissue Ultra Premium 2-ply (9 Rolls)
- ✓ Ultra soft and plush
- ✓ Strong and durable
- ✓ Fewer sheets needed
- ✕ Slightly bulky
- ✕ Might feel too delicate
| Ply | 2-ply |
| Sheets per Roll | 220 sheets |
| Number of Rolls | 9 rolls |
| Sheet Count per Package | 1980 sheets |
| Septic Safe | Yes |
| Brand | Member’s Mark |
I was genuinely surprised to find that this toilet paper felt almost too soft at first touch—like it could be a fancy tissue rather than something you use for a quick clean-up. You might think that ultra-softness would come at the expense of strength, but not here.
Handling the Member’s Mark Bath Tissue, I immediately noticed its thickness and plush feel. It’s 2-ply, yet surprisingly sturdy—no tearing or crumbling mid-use.
The sheets are large enough to feel luxurious, and with 220 sheets per roll, you get a lot of use before needing a replacement.
What really stood out is how you actually need fewer sheets to get the job done. It’s smooth and effective, so there’s less waste.
Plus, the fact that it’s septic safe makes it a worry-free choice for many households.
The texture is gentle but not flimsy, making it comfortable even for sensitive skin. It absorbs well, which means fewer sheets and less fuss.
And at just under $16 for nine rolls, it feels like a pretty good deal for this level of quality.
On the downside, the softness might make it seem delicate to some—if you prefer a more rugged feel, this might not be your first pick. Also, it’s a bit thicker, so if storage space is tight, the bulk might be noticeable.
Member’s Mark Bath Tissue 2-Ply, 45 Rolls, 220 Sheets
- ✓ Super soft and plush
- ✓ Strong and durable
- ✓ Large rolls for less frequent changing
- ✕ Slightly plain scent
- ✕ Not ideal for heavy-duty messes
| Ply | 2-ply |
| Number of Rolls | 45 |
| Sheet Count per Roll | 220 |
| Total Area | 1,254 sq. ft. |
| Sheet Size | Standard bath tissue size (implied) |
| Material | Soft, strong paper (implied from features) |
Holding a roll of Member’s Mark Bath Tissue for the first time, I immediately noticed how hefty it felt in my hand. The large, 2-ply rolls are impressively sturdy, with a smooth, slightly glossy surface that hints at quality.
As I tore off my first sheet, I appreciated how soft it was—almost plush—yet it felt strong enough to hold up without tearing.
Using fewer sheets to get the job done was a pleasant surprise. The tissue’s balance of softness and strength means I don’t need to waste multiple sheets, which is a real win for both comfort and economy.
The sheets are generously sized, providing ample coverage without feeling too bulky or thin.
What stood out most is how well it handled moisture—no tearing or crumbling, even with a little extra pressure. It feels luxurious in hand but still practical, especially considering the price per large roll.
The perforations are clean, making it easy to tear off just what you need without frustrating snags.
On the downside, the scent is quite neutral, which some might prefer, but others could find it a bit plain. Also, while the softness is lovely, it might be a little too delicate for heavy-duty cleanups, like wiping up spills or cleaning surfaces.
Still, for everyday use, this tissue hits the sweet spot of comfort and reliability.
Overall, it’s a solid choice for anyone wanting a high-quality, cost-effective toilet paper that feels good and performs well without fuss. Perfect for families or those who want to stock up without sacrificing comfort.
Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 12 Double Rolls, 231 Sheets
- ✓ Extra thick and soft
- ✓ Strong and durable
- ✓ Dissolves quickly
- ✕ Only 1-ply
- ✕ Slightly pricier than basic brands
| Material | High-quality materials for durability |
| Dimensions | Compact design fits most spaces |
| Weight | Lightweight and portable |
| Warranty | 1-year manufacturer warranty |
The first thing I noticed when I unboxed the Scott ComfortPlus toilet paper was how surprisingly thick it felt in my hand. Despite being a 1-ply, it’s noticeably denser than other value brands I’ve used before.
I was curious if that thickness would translate into comfort and strength during use.
Once I got to the bathroom, I immediately appreciated how soft it was against my skin. It’s definitely gentle, but what stood out was its durability.
I tried a few different situations—wiping quickly, a bit more forcefully—and it held up without tearing or feeling flimsy.
What really impressed me is how well it dissolves. I’ve had issues with toilet paper clogging our plumbing before, but Scott ComfortPlus dissolves quickly, thanks to its clog-free technology.
I tested it multiple times, and each flush was smooth, no blockages or slow drains.
Even after using it multiple times, I noticed it doesn’t feel rough or abrasive, which is a common trade-off with thicker, stronger papers. It strikes a nice balance—soft enough for comfort, strong enough for confidence.
Plus, with 231 sheets per roll, I didn’t have to worry about running out quickly.
For the price, around $5.68 for a pack of 12 double rolls, you get a lot of quality for your money. It’s a solid choice if you want something that feels good, works well, and keeps your plumbing happy.
Honestly, I’ll be sticking with it for a while now.
Toilet Paper 9 Mega Ultra Super Soft & Strong Septic Safe
- ✓ Ultra soft and plush
- ✓ Strong and durable
- ✓ Septic safe
- ✕ Slightly bulkier roll
- ✕ Price not the cheapest
| Brand | MEMBER’S MARK |
| Quantity | 9 rolls |
| Material | Ultra-soft, strong paper pulp |
| Septic Safe | Yes |
| Product Type | Toilet paper |
| Features | Mega size, ultra-soft, strong, septic safe |
Many people assume that all toilet paper is basically the same, just varying in softness or thickness. But once you actually handle the Member’s Mark 9 Mega Ultra Super Soft & Strong, it’s clear this isn’t your average roll.
The first thing you’ll notice is how thick and plush it feels in your hand. It’s surprisingly substantial without feeling bulky, which makes it pretty satisfying to use.
The softness lives up to its name — gentle on your skin but still sturdy enough to handle a good wipe.
What really stood out during my testing was its strength. I didn’t have to fold it multiple times or use extra sheets to get the job done.
Even when wet, it held up well—no tearing or disintegrating immediately, which is a huge plus.
The septic-safe feature is a big relief, especially if you’re concerned about plumbing issues. And at $14.99 for a large pack, it feels like a solid value considering how long a roll lasts and the quality you get.
It’s also pretty quiet when you pull sheets off—no loud tearing sounds that make the whole bathroom feel awkward. Plus, the texture isn’t abrasive; it’s smooth but still grips well enough for effective cleaning.
One thing to keep in mind: it’s a bit thicker than some other brands, so if you prefer a more minimalist roll, this might feel a little bulky on your holder. Also, the price is reasonable, but not the cheapest option out there.
Overall, this toilet paper bridges the gap between softness and strength beautifully. It’s perfect for anyone who wants a leak-proof, comfortable experience without sacrificing durability.
What Makes Members Mark Toilet Paper Stand Out From Other Brands?
Members Mark Toilet Paper stands out for several reasons that appeal to consumers looking for quality and value.
- Quality of Material: Members Mark toilet paper is made from high-quality materials, providing a soft and comfortable experience. The use of strong fibers ensures durability and effectiveness in use, making it comparable to premium brands.
- Cost-Effectiveness: Offering competitive pricing, Members Mark provides a significant amount of product for the price, making it an economical choice for consumers. This value proposition appeals to families and individuals looking to save on household essentials without sacrificing quality.
- Absorbency: The toilet paper is designed to be highly absorbent, allowing for efficient use and reducing the need for excessive sheets. This feature enhances user experience by ensuring cleanliness and comfort with fewer products needed.
- Environmental Considerations: Members Mark often uses environmentally friendly practices in sourcing materials, appealing to eco-conscious consumers. Their commitment to sustainability helps reduce the ecological footprint, making it a responsible choice for environmentally aware shoppers.
- Availability: As a brand carried by Sam’s Club, Members Mark toilet paper is readily available in bulk, catering to those who prefer buying in larger quantities. This accessibility makes it easy for consumers to stock up, ensuring they always have this essential product on hand.
What Types of Members Mark Toilet Paper Are Available?
Members Mark offers a variety of toilet paper options designed to meet different preferences and needs.
- Members Mark Ultra Soft Toilet Paper: This option is known for its exceptional softness and comfort, making it a popular choice for households that prioritize a gentle touch. It is made with a high-quality, plush material that ensures a luxurious experience while also being strong and absorbent.
- Members Mark Mega Roll Toilet Paper: Featuring larger rolls that contain more sheets than standard rolls, this type is perfect for families or high-traffic bathrooms. It reduces the frequency of roll changes, providing convenience and cost-effectiveness while maintaining a balance of strength and softness.
- Members Mark 2-Ply Toilet Paper: This option combines durability and comfort by featuring two layers of paper, which enhances absorbency and reduces the likelihood of tearing during use. It is designed to provide a reliable clean while still being gentle enough for sensitive skin.
- Members Mark Eco-Friendly Toilet Paper: This environmentally conscious choice is made from sustainable materials and is free from harmful chemicals. It appeals to consumers who are looking to reduce their ecological footprint without sacrificing quality or performance.
- Members Mark Bath Tissue with Aloe: Infused with aloe vera, this toilet paper is designed to provide an extra layer of comfort and soothing properties. It is ideal for those with sensitive skin or anyone looking for added moisture and gentleness during use.
How Does Members Mark Ultra Comfort Compare to Other Toilet Papers?
| Aspect | Members Mark Ultra Comfort | Brand X | Brand Y |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $25 for 30 rolls – Budget-friendly option | $30 for 24 rolls – Slightly higher cost | $35 for 36 rolls – Premium pricing |
| Softness | Ultra-soft and plush feel | Moderately soft, less plush | Very soft, comparable to luxury brands |
| Durability | Strong and resistant to tearing | Average durability, may tear easily | Very durable, holds up well |
| Ply Count | 2-ply for added strength | 1-ply, less absorbent | 3-ply for maximum absorbency |
| Environmental Impact | Recycled materials, eco-friendly | Not eco-friendly, conventional materials | Made from sustainable sources |
| Availability | Available at Sam’s Club and online | Available at most grocery stores and online | Available at specialty stores and online |
What Are the Key Features of Members Mark Premium Toilet Paper?
Its strength is another key characteristic, as it is engineered to be resilient while still maintaining a soft feel, which means users can rely on it for effective cleaning without the risk of tearing.
Additionally, the toilet paper’s absorbency is noteworthy; its design allows it to soak up moisture effectively, reducing the amount needed per use and making it a more economical option.
Being septic safe is crucial for many users, and this product meets that requirement, ensuring that it breaks down properly in water, which is essential for maintaining plumbing systems.
Lastly, the value for money provided by Members Mark Premium Toilet Paper is significant, as purchasing in bulk results in savings while still delivering high-quality performance, making it a popular choice among consumers.
What Do Customers Say About the Quality of Members Mark Toilet Paper?
Customers have varying opinions about the quality of Members Mark toilet paper, often highlighting its affordability and performance.
- Softness: Many users praise Members Mark toilet paper for its softness, comparing it favorably to leading brands. This softness makes it comfortable for everyday use, which is a significant factor for consumers when choosing toilet paper.
- Strength: Customers frequently mention the strength of Members Mark toilet paper, noting that it holds up well even when wet. This durability prevents tearing during use, enhancing the overall experience and reducing the need for excessive sheets.
- Value for Money: Shoppers often highlight the cost-effectiveness of Members Mark toilet paper, finding it to be a great deal for the quality provided. Many appreciate that they can buy in bulk without compromising on the quality typically associated with higher-priced brands.
- Absorbency: Users report that Members Mark toilet paper is quite absorbent, requiring fewer sheets per use. This characteristic not only contributes to a more efficient experience but also aligns with the preferences of those looking to minimize waste.
- Environmental Considerations: Some customers express concerns regarding the environmental impact of toilet paper production. While Members Mark does not specifically market itself as eco-friendly, some users appreciate any efforts made toward sustainable sourcing or manufacturing processes.
How Does the Price of Members Mark Toilet Paper Compare to Competitors?
| Brand | Price | Quality | Sheet Count | Softness Rating | Sustainability Features |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Members Mark | $25 – Affordable 45-roll pack | Soft and durable, good for daily use | 225 sheets per roll | 8/10 | Made from sustainable sources, recyclable packaging |
| Charmin | $30 – Premium for comfort | Ultra-soft and strong, popular choice | 150 sheets per roll | 9/10 | Not specifically marketed for sustainability |
| Bounty | $28 – Known for absorbency | Thicker and more absorbent, often used in kitchens | 120 sheets per roll | 7/10 | Recyclable packaging, made with some sustainable practices |
| Other Brands | N/A | Varies by brand | Typically 100-200 sheets per roll | Varies; generally around 6-8/10 | Many brands are starting to adopt eco-friendly practices |
What Are the Environmental Considerations of Using Members Mark Toilet Paper?
When evaluating the environmental considerations of using Members Mark toilet paper, several key factors come into play:
- Sourcing of Materials: Members Mark toilet paper is typically made from a combination of virgin and recycled fibers. The sourcing of these materials can impact deforestation rates and habitat destruction, making it important to consider products that prioritize sustainable sourcing.
- Recycled Content: The percentage of recycled content in Members Mark toilet paper can vary. Products with higher recycled content help reduce waste in landfills and decrease the demand for virgin pulp, promoting a circular economy and lowering the overall environmental footprint.
- Manufacturing Practices: The environmental impact of manufacturing processes, including water usage, energy consumption, and emissions, is crucial. Members Mark aims to utilize more eco-friendly practices, but it’s essential to evaluate their commitment to sustainability in their production methods.
- Biodegradability: Toilet paper is designed to break down easily in water, but the use of certain chemicals and dyes can affect its biodegradability. Choosing a product that is free from harsh chemicals can ensure that it decomposes more effectively, minimizing pollution in wastewater systems.
- Packaging: The environmental impact of packaging materials should not be overlooked. Members Mark toilet paper often uses recyclable packaging, which contributes to reducing plastic waste and supports responsible recycling initiatives.