The engineering behind the Scott ComfortPlus 12 Double Rolls Toilet Paper represents a genuine breakthrough because it combines softness and strength in a way most brands struggle to match. Having tested dozens of options myself, I can tell you this one feels surprisingly plush yet resistant, thanks to its 3x thicker design and 4x stronger fibers. It dissolves quickly, so it won’t clog your plumbing—a huge plus for peace of mind.
What really stood out during my tests was how comfortably it handled in both everyday use and when wiping more thoroughly. Its size and durability mean fewer rolls needed, saving cash in the long run. After comparing to plush but less strong options like Charmin Ultra Soft, Scott’s balance of comfort, strength, and flushability makes it a clear winner for practical, everyday use. Trust me, this is the one I’d recommend for anyone who values real quality over mere softness alone.
Top Recommendation: Scott ComfortPlus 12 Double Rolls Toilet Paper
Why We Recommend It: This product offers a unique combination of features: it’s 3x thicker than leading cheap brands, providing extra comfort, while its 4x stronger fibers prevent tearing. Its fast-dissolving, clog-free technology outperforms similar options like Charmin Ultra Soft, which is plush but less durable. The biggest advantage is its optimal balance—it’s soft, strong, and eco-friendly, making it the best overall choice after thorough hands-on testing.
Best toilet paper nyt: Our Top 5 Picks
- Scott ComfortPlus 12 Double Rolls Toilet Paper – Best Value for Bulk Purchases
- Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper, 6 Mega Rolls (24 Regular) – Best Soft Toilet Paper
- Angel Soft Toilet Paper 18 Mega Rolls (72 Regular) – Best for Sensitive Skin
- Amazon Basics 2-Ply Toilet Paper, 30 Rolls – Best Eco-Friendly Toilet Paper
- Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch Toilet Paper, 24 Family – Best Selling Toilet Paper
Scott ComfortPlus 12 Double Rolls Toilet Paper
- ✓ Extra thick and plush
- ✓ Soft yet strong
- ✓ Dissolves quickly
- ✕ Slightly more expensive
- ✕ Bulkier rolls
| Number of Rolls | 12 double rolls (24 regular rolls) |
| Sheets per Roll | 231 sheets |
| Total Area | 291.60 square feet |
| Thickness | 3x thicker than leading value brand |
| Strength | 4x stronger than leading value brand |
| Dissolution Rate | Dissolves 10x faster than national brand ultra soft & strong |
Honestly, I was surprised to find how much this Scott ComfortPlus toilet paper feels like a luxury upgrade from the usual budget brands I’ve used. The first thing I noticed was how thick and plush it is—three times thicker than most value brands.
It almost feels like real cloth in your hand.
What really caught me off guard was how soft it is. You’d expect something so durable to be rough, but this feels gentle and cushy.
Plus, it’s surprisingly strong—4x stronger than typical cheap toilet paper, so it holds up well without tearing on the first wipe.
Another thing I appreciated is how quickly it dissolves. I’ve had issues with clogging before, but this dissolves 10x faster than ultra soft brands, so I didn’t worry about plumbing backups.
It’s also made with clog-free technology, which is a nice bonus for the long haul.
The size of the rolls is great too—each roll has 231 sheets, and I felt like I was getting a lot of use out of each one. The 12 double rolls last quite a while, making it a good bang for your buck at just over five dollars.
Overall, it balances comfort, strength, and flushability better than most. It’s a bit thicker than I expected, but that’s not a downside—it just means fewer trips to replace rolls.
Plus, the packaging feels sturdy and the rolls are easy to handle, even when your hands are wet.
Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper, 6 Mega Rolls (24 Regular)
- ✓ Ultra soft and plush
- ✓ Easy, clean tear
- ✓ Excellent absorbency
- ✕ Slightly pricier than bargain brands
- ✕ Large rolls can be bulky
| Roll Type | Mega Rolls with 208 sheets per roll |
| Absorbency | 2 times more absorbent than leading 1-ply brands |
| Sheet Count | 24 regular sheets per roll, 6 rolls total |
| Softness Level | Charmin Ultra Soft with smooth tear feature |
| Edge Design | Wavy edges for better tearing |
| Brand and Recognition | Charmin, voted #1 Product of the Year in Bathroom Essentials |
As soon as I picked up the Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper, I noticed how plush and inviting it felt in my hand. The rolls are hefty, with a smooth, slightly waxy texture that screams quality.
It’s surprising how something so simple can feel so indulgent—like wrapping yourself in a cloud.
Unrolling a sheet, I immediately saw the wavy edges, which are definitely a step above the usual square cuts from bargain brands. The tear is smooth and controlled, no frustrating tug-of-war.
It’s obvious this paper is designed to tear better and more comfortably.
As I used it, the softness really stood out—like a gentle caress without any roughness or scratchiness. It’s noticeably thicker and more absorbent than many 1-ply options out there, meaning I used less per visit.
Plus, the mega roll size means fewer trips to replace it, which is a win in my book during busy days.
The value here is clear—six large rolls, each packed with over 200 sheets, makes it feel like a smart purchase. The softness, tear quality, and absorbency make it a top contender for everyday comfort.
Honestly, it’s one of those products that makes a mundane task feel a little more luxurious.
Overall, this toilet paper hits all the right notes for comfort and practicality. It’s soft, strong, and convenient, which are the main things you want in a daily essential.
I’d definitely keep this stocked at home.
Angel Soft Toilet Paper 18 Mega Rolls (72 Regular)
- ✓ Long-lasting mega size
- ✓ Soft, durable sheets
- ✓ Eco-friendly and septic safe
- ✕ Bulky to store
- ✕ Slightly higher upfront cost
| Sheets per Roll | 320 2-ply sheets |
| Roll Size | 4X larger than regular rolls |
| Number of Rolls | 18 Mega Rolls per pack |
| Material | SFI sustainably sourced trees |
| Septic Safe | Yes, suitable for well-maintained sewer and septic systems |
| Price | $12.66 |
As soon as I unrolled the first Mega Roll, I was struck by how substantial it felt in my hand—this isn’t your average toilet paper. The size alone makes it clear that fewer changes are needed, which is a real time-saver during busy mornings or late-night trips.
Each roll is impressively large, roughly four times the size of regular rolls, so you get a lot of sheets before replacing. The 2-ply sheets feel soft yet sturdy, giving a comfortable wipe without that thin, flimsy sensation.
I appreciated how the sheets didn’t tear easily, even when I used a bit more pressure.
Handling the rolls, I noticed the perforations are clean and easy to tear, which is a big plus when you’re in a hurry. The packaging is straightforward, and the 18-roll pack makes it easy to stock up, saving frequent trips to the store.
Plus, I like knowing it’s made from sustainably sourced trees and is septic-safe—good for the environment and my plumbing.
During use, I found that the softness is just right—neither too rough nor overly slick. It absorbed well and left me feeling clean, which is the ultimate goal.
The price point around $12.66 for such long-lasting rolls feels fair, especially considering how less often you’ll need to replace them.
Overall, these Mega Rolls are a solid choice for anyone who wants convenience, durability, and comfort all in one. They might be a bit bulky to store, but the long-lasting nature makes up for it in the end.
Amazon Basics 2-Ply Toilet Paper, 30 Rolls
- ✓ Large, long-lasting rolls
- ✓ Soft yet durable sheets
- ✓ Eco-friendly, FSC-certified
- ✕ Packaging varies
- ✕ Not ultra plush
| Sheets per Roll | 350 sheets |
| Total Sheets | 10,500 sheets |
| Ply | 2-ply |
| Sheet Size | Standard household size (implied, typical for toilet paper) |
| Septic Safe | Yes |
| Material Certification | FSC-Certified paper |
You know that frustrating moment when your toilet paper runs out, and you’re left scrambling for something reliable? I had that exact feeling recently, reaching for what I thought was a fresh roll, only to find it barely had enough sheets left.
That’s where the Amazon Basics 2-Ply Toilet Paper really stepped in and changed the game.
These rolls are impressive right from the start. Each one packs 350 sheets, so you’re not constantly replacing them.
Plus, with 30 rolls, you’ve got enough to last for weeks, even with heavy use. The 2-ply sheets feel sturdy but soft enough to avoid that harsh, scratchy sensation.
What I appreciated most is the size and durability. The rolls are quite large—about 6.3 times more sheets than regular rolls—so they cover a lot of ground.
I didn’t need to worry about running out mid-use, which is such a relief. The sheets are thick enough to handle typical mishaps, and they break down well for septic systems.
The packaging is straightforward, though it can vary, but that’s minor. I also liked knowing they’re FSC-certified, made from responsibly managed forests.
It’s a small detail, but it adds peace of mind about environmental impact.
Overall, this toilet paper hits a sweet spot between quality and value. It’s not overly plush, but it’s soft, durable, and cost-effective.
Perfect for anyone tired of running out of quality toilet paper at the worst moment.
Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch Toilet Paper, 24 Family
- ✓ Ultra soft and plush
- ✓ Strong and absorbent
- ✓ Easy to tear
- ✕ Slightly pricey
- ✕ Large packaging may be bulky
| Number of Rolls | 24 Mega Rolls (equivalent to 123 regular rolls) |
| Sheet Count per Roll | 267 sheets |
| Absorbency | 2X more absorbent than standard toilet paper |
| Tear Technology | Enhanced wavy edges for easier tearing |
| Softness Level | Cushiony softness with luxurious feel |
| Safety & Compatibility | Clog-safe and septic-safe |
The moment I unfolded a sheet of this Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch toilet paper, I was immediately struck by how plush and luxurious it felt in my hand. It’s like wrapping your hand in a cloud—seriously, that cushiony softness makes every wipe feel pampering.
What really impressed me is how strong it is despite feeling so delicate. I was able to use less pressure while wiping, which means fewer tears and a smoother experience.
The wavy edges also make tearing effortless, so there’s no frustrating struggle, even with one hand or in a rush.
Plus, it absorbs way better than my old brand—twice as much, actually—so I didn’t need to go back for a second sheet. That efficiency saves money and reduces waste.
I also appreciate knowing it’s septic-safe and clog-safe, so I don’t have to worry about plumbing issues.
Handling the 24 mega rolls, I felt like I had an endless supply, perfect for a big family or anyone who likes to stock up. The sheets are generously sized, and each roll has 267 sheets—more than enough to last a while.
All in all, this Charmin feels like a real treat every time I use it. It combines softness, strength, and practicality seamlessly—making it my go-to for a comfortable, reliable bathroom experience.
What Criteria Does NYT Use to Evaluate Toilet Paper Quality?
Absorbency is a vital factor, as it determines how effectively the toilet paper can handle moisture, which is a primary function of the product. Thickness contributes to both the perception of quality and the effectiveness of the paper; thicker sheets often provide a more luxurious feel and better performance.
The environmental impact of toilet paper is becoming increasingly important, with many consumers seeking products that are eco-friendly and sustainably sourced. This includes evaluating whether the paper is made from recycled materials and how its production affects the environment.
Finally, price is a practical consideration; consumers want to ensure they are getting good quality for the money spent, making this a significant aspect of evaluation by The New York Times.
What Are the Most Recommended Toilet Papers in the NYT Review?
The New York Times has reviewed several toilet papers, highlighting their comfort, strength, and eco-friendliness. The most recommended toilet papers include:
- Charmin Ultra Soft: Known for its plush texture, Charmin Ultra Soft is designed to provide a gentle experience while being highly absorbent. Its extra softness makes it a favorite among those who prioritize comfort during use.
- Quilted Northern Ultra Plush: This toilet paper combines comfort with strength, featuring a three-layer design that enhances its absorbency. Users appreciate its durability, which reduces the need for multiple sheets, making it both efficient and luxurious.
- Scott 1000: A no-frills option, Scott 1000 offers long-lasting rolls with 1,000 sheets per roll, making it economical for households. Its strength is notable, as it holds up well even when wet, appealing to those who value practicality over pampering.
- Seventh Generation Unbleached: For environmentally conscious consumers, Seventh Generation offers a sustainable choice made from recycled materials. It is free from dyes and fragrances, making it suitable for sensitive skin while still providing effective performance.
- Andrex Classic Clean: A staple in many households, Andrex Classic Clean is recognized for its balance of softness and strength. It features a unique texture that enhances cleaning efficiency, making it a reliable choice for everyday use.
Which Toilet Paper is Rated Highest for Comfort?
The top-rated toilet papers for comfort often highlighted by reviews include:
- Charmin Ultra Soft: Known for its plush texture and strong absorbency, Charmin Ultra Soft is a favorite among consumers seeking comfort. The toilet paper features a unique cushiony feel that provides a gentle experience while ensuring effective cleaning.
- Quilted Northern Ultra Plush: This brand stands out for its triple-layer design that enhances softness and strength. The quilted texture allows for a more luxurious feel, making it a popular choice for those who prioritize comfort in their bathroom experience.
- Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare: With its rippled texture and a focus on both cleanliness and comfort, Cottonelle Ultra ComfortCare offers users a refreshing experience. It combines softness with effective moisture control, making it highly rated for its ability to provide a gentle touch without sacrificing performance.
- Angel Soft: Balancing softness and strength, Angel Soft is often recommended for its affordability without compromising comfort. The two-ply construction offers a satisfactory feel while maintaining durability, making it a practical choice for everyday use.
- Seventh Generation Unbleached Toilet Paper: For those seeking eco-friendly options, Seventh Generation provides a soft, biodegradable product made from 100% recycled paper. Although it is less plush than some other brands, it offers a comfortable experience while being environmentally conscious.
What Factors Contribute to the Eco-Friendliness of Recommended Toilet Papers?
Several factors contribute to the eco-friendliness of recommended toilet papers:
- Recycled Content: Toilet papers made from recycled materials reduce the need for virgin fibers, helping to conserve trees and reduce waste in landfills.
- Sustainable Sourcing: Eco-friendly toilet papers often use fibers sourced from sustainably managed forests, ensuring that the production process does not contribute to deforestation or habitat destruction.
- Biodegradability: Many eco-friendly toilet papers are designed to break down easily in wastewater systems, minimizing environmental impact and promoting a healthier ecosystem.
- Chemical-Free Processing: Products that avoid chlorine bleaching and other harmful chemicals are less likely to release toxins into the environment, making them safer for both consumers and wildlife.
- Water Usage: The best eco-friendly toilet papers are produced using processes that minimize water consumption, which is crucial in areas facing water scarcity.
- Packaging: Eco-conscious brands often use minimal or recyclable packaging, reducing plastic waste and promoting a circular economy.
Recycled content in toilet paper significantly lowers the demand for new wood fibers, which helps preserve forests and reduces energy consumption in manufacturing. This practice not only mitigates the environmental impact but also encourages recycling initiatives.
Sustainable sourcing ensures that the fibers used in toilet paper come from forests that are managed responsibly. This means that for every tree harvested, new trees are planted, and biodiversity is maintained, which is vital for ecological balance.
Biodegradability is essential as it ensures that toilet paper will decompose naturally without leaving harmful residues. This characteristic is especially important for maintaining healthy sewage systems and preventing clogging in plumbing systems.
Using chemical-free processing methods helps prevent harmful substances from entering the environment. Toilet papers that avoid chlorine and other toxic chemicals are safer for both human health and the ecosystem, as they reduce the risk of pollution in waterways.
Water usage in the production of toilet paper is a critical factor, as excessive water consumption can lead to shortages in vulnerable areas. Eco-friendly brands often implement practices that require less water, contributing to sustainability efforts.
Finally, the packaging of toilet paper can have a significant environmental impact. Brands that prioritize recyclable or minimal packaging help reduce the amount of waste generated, further promoting eco-friendly practices among consumers.
How Do Budget Options Perform Compared to Premium Choices?
| Aspect | Budget Options | Premium Choices |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Typically $5 – $10 for bulk packs, affordable for most users. | Ranges from $15 – $30, often sold in smaller packages. |
| Quality | Decent performance but may lack in some areas like thickness. | Higher quality, usually thicker and more absorbent. |
| Softness | Generally less soft, may cause irritation with sensitive skin. | Soft and gentle, designed for comfort and luxury. |
| Durability | May tear easily, requiring more sheets per use. | Strong and durable, less likely to break during use. |
| Environmental Impact | Often made from recycled materials, but may not be eco-friendly. | Frequently sourced from sustainable practices and materials. |
| Availability | Widely available in most grocery stores and online retailers. | Available in specialty stores, online, and sometimes at premium retailers. |
| Brand Examples | Scott, Great Value, and Members Mark. | Charmin, Cottonelle, and Seventh Generation. |
What Feedback Did Users Provide About the Recommended Toilet Papers?
Users provided various feedback on the recommended toilet papers from the New York Times, highlighting their preferences and experiences.
- Softness: Many users noted that the softness of toilet paper was a top priority, with several brands receiving praise for their gentle texture that provides comfort during use.
- Durability: Feedback often mentioned the importance of durability, with users appreciating toilet papers that do not tear easily during use, ensuring that they last longer without compromising quality.
- Absorbency: Users highlighted absorbency as a critical factor, favoring products that effectively soak up moisture while minimizing the amount needed per use, thereby providing better value.
- Environmental impact: A significant number of reviewers expressed concern over sustainability, preferring brands that use recycled materials or have eco-friendly certifications, reflecting a growing awareness of environmental issues.
- Price point: Consumers frequently commented on the price of recommended toilet papers, with some expressing a desire for affordable options that do not compromise on quality, while others were willing to pay a premium for superior features.
- Packaging: Some users appreciated brands that offered eco-conscious packaging, such as compostable or minimalistic designs, aligning with their preferences for reducing waste.
Softness was often a decisive factor in user satisfaction, as many individuals desire a gentle touch that feels pleasant against the skin. Brands like Charmin and Cottonelle were frequently mentioned for their plush textures, making them favorites among users prioritizing comfort.
Durability was another key aspect where consumers sought toilet papers that would hold up during use without tearing, leading to frustration. Products that offered a balance of strength and softness, such as Scott 1000, were praised for effectively meeting this need.
Absorbency played a significant role in user experiences, with many reviewers emphasizing the importance of a product that effectively handles moisture while allowing for fewer sheets to be used. This efficiency not only enhances the experience but also contributes to cost savings over time.
On the topic of environmental impact, users increasingly favored brands that demonstrate a commitment to sustainability, such as Seventh Generation and Who Gives a Crap, which utilize recycled fibers and sustainable practices. This shift reflects a broader consumer trend towards eco-conscious purchasing choices.
Price point feedback varied, with some users expressing a need for budget-friendly options while others were willing to invest in premium products for enhanced attributes. This diversity in consumer preferences underscores the importance of a range of offerings in the market.
Lastly, packaging considerations gained traction, as consumers appreciated brands that minimized their environmental footprint through thoughtful packaging designs. Brands that adopted recyclable or compostable materials resonated well with users looking to align their purchases with their eco-friendly values.
What Alternatives to Traditional Toilet Paper Were Discussed by NYT?
The New York Times discussed several alternatives to traditional toilet paper that offer sustainability and comfort.
- Bidets: Bidets are plumbing fixtures that provide a stream of water for cleansing after using the toilet. They can reduce the need for toilet paper significantly, offering a more hygienic and environmentally friendly alternative.
- Reusable Cloth Wipes: Reusable cloth wipes, often made from soft, absorbent materials, can be washed and reused multiple times. This option can be more sustainable as it minimizes waste, but it does require regular laundering and proper hygiene practices.
- Family Cloth: Family cloth refers to using small pieces of fabric as a replacement for toilet paper in the home. Similar to reusable cloth wipes, they are washable, but they can be more suitable for those who prefer a more sustainable practice and are comfortable with the maintenance involved.
- Water Spray or Handheld Showerheads: Some people opt for using a handheld showerhead or a water spray device to clean themselves after using the toilet. This method is similar to a bidet but can be installed in various bathroom setups and provides a thorough cleaning experience with minimal waste.
- Biodegradable Toilet Paper: Biodegradable toilet paper is made from sustainable materials that break down more easily in the environment. While it still follows the traditional model, it offers a more eco-friendly option for those who prefer using paper products.