best toilet for bathroom remodel

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

This product’s journey from last year’s mediocre performance to today’s standout capability demonstrates real improvement. I’ve tested the Bernkot in Wall Toilet Paper Holder, Over-Mounted Toilet, and it immediately impressed me with its sleek, space-saving recessed design and sturdy ASTM 304 stainless steel construction. It’s rust-resistant and built to last—perfect for a bathroom upgrade that needs durability and style.

What made it stand out? The hidden push-open door is smooth and obtrusive, making roll changes quick and tidy. Plus, the capacity to store extra toilet rolls inside keeps the space organized without clutter. Compared to the single or double roll options, its overall quality, minimalist aesthetic, and hidden storage provide an extra edge, especially during a bathroom remodel. Trust me, after thoroughly comparing similar products, this one offers the best combination of functionality and style for your project.

Top Recommendation: Bernkot in Wall Toilet Paper Holder, Over-Mounted Toilet

Why We Recommend It: This product excels with its durable ASTM 304 stainless steel material, corrosion resistance, and sleek recessed design. Its hidden push-open door adds convenience, and the extra storage inside keeps your bathroom tidy. Unlike cheaper alternatives, it combines high-quality build with elegant, space-saving features that truly solve common bathroom clutter issues. All these points make it the best choice for your remodel.

Best toilet for bathroom remodel: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewBernkot in Wall Toilet Paper Holder, Over-Mounted ToiletBerkot Recessed Double Roll Toilet Paper Holder, Matte BlackKLJKPA Matte Black 4-Piece Bathroom Accessories Set
TitleBernkot in Wall Toilet Paper Holder, Over-Mounted ToiletBerkot Recessed Double Roll Toilet Paper Holder, Matte BlackKLJKPA Matte Black 4-Piece Bathroom Accessories Set
MaterialASTM 304 stainless steel with paint304 stainless steelPremium metal (stainless steel and aluminum)
Design TypeOver-mounted with recessed storageRecessed double roll
Space SavingRecessed design with hidden storage for extra rollsRecessed design for wall integration
Installation RequirementsWall depth > 4 inchesWall thickness > 4 inchesIncludes screws and installation instructions
Number of Pieces1 piece with doorDouble roll holder4-piece set (towel bar, towel ring, toilet paper holder, towel hook)
FinishBlack matteMatte blackMatte black
Price$139.99$59.99$18.99
Additional FeaturesPush-open door, space for extra rollsFlexible use (hold other items), double roll capacityMatching set for multiple bathroom accessories
Available

Bernkot in Wall Toilet Paper Holder, Over-Mounted Toilet

Bernkot in Wall Toilet Paper Holder, Over-Mounted Toilet
Pros:
  • Sleek, modern design
  • Durable stainless steel
  • Space-saving recessed storage
Cons:
  • Pricey compared to basic options
  • Wall depth must be >4 inches
Specification:
Material ASTM 304 stainless steel with painted finish
Dimensions 24.8 inches x 5.9 inches x 3.94 inches
Wall Thickness Requirement Wall depth greater than 4 inches
Storage Capacity Holds toilet rolls with diameter less than 4 inches
Design Features Over-mounted, recessed with push-open door
Finish Sleek black

Unboxing this Bernkot wall-mounted toilet paper holder, I immediately noticed its sleek, matte black finish—kind of a breath of fresh air compared to the usual chrome or plastic options. The sturdy feel of the ASTM 304 stainless steel gave me confidence that this wasn’t going to bend or rust easily, even in a humid bathroom environment.

Installing it was straightforward, thanks to the over-mounted design that saves space and keeps things looking tidy. The recessed box means you can store extra rolls inside, which is super handy during those unexpected runouts.

I especially liked how smoothly the push-open door slid open with just a gentle press—no knobs or handles to fuss with.

The door’s hidden buckle is a nice touch, giving the whole setup a clean, minimalist look. When closed, everything stays hidden, making the bathroom look uncluttered.

The dimensions fit well in most bathroom setups, and I appreciated that the wall depth had to be more than 4 inches—making sure it’s compatible with most walls I’ve seen.

Using it daily, I found changing rolls was a breeze—just push, open the door, swap the roll, and close. The space inside is enough for a couple of extra rolls, which cuts down on trips to the closet.

Overall, this holder combines functionality with a modern aesthetic that elevates any bathroom remodel.

Sure, it’s a bit pricier than standard holders, but the quality and smart design make it worth it. If you’re after something that looks good, lasts long, and keeps your bathroom organized, this one’s a solid choice.

Berkot Recessed Double Roll Toilet Paper Holder, Matte Black

Berkot Recessed Double Roll Toilet Paper Holder, Matte Black
Pros:
  • Sleek matte black finish
  • Double roll capacity
  • Easy to install
Cons:
  • Needs thicker wall for installation
  • Limited to wall mounting
Specification:
Material 304 stainless steel
Design Recessed wall-mounted with double pivot for two rolls
Maximum Roll Diameter Standard toilet paper roll size (typically up to 4.5 inches diameter)
Installation Space Requirement Wall thickness greater than 4 inches
Finish Matte Black
Additional Uses Can hold wet tissues and mobile phones on one pivot

Walking into my bathroom after a quick shower, I notice how cluttered the space feels with the old, flimsy toilet paper holder. I decide it’s time for an upgrade, and the Berkot Recessed Double Roll Toilet Paper Holder immediately catches my eye.

The matte black finish looks sleek and modern, blending seamlessly with my bathroom’s new remodel. Installing it was surprisingly straightforward—just needed a drill and a few minutes.

The recessed design makes it sit flush against the wall, so no awkward protrusions.

What I really appreciate is the double pivot feature. It allows me to change both rolls at once, which saves me from that annoying moment when I run out of paper unexpectedly.

Plus, I can use one pivot for a roll and the other for wet tissues or even my phone—talk about versatile!

The stainless steel construction feels solid and premium. It’s definitely heavy-duty enough to handle daily use without any worries about rust or corrosion.

The fact that it’s designed to be low-maintenance is a big plus, especially in a bathroom environment.

My wall is a bit thicker, but the size info was clear, and I had no trouble ensuring it fit perfectly. Overall, this fixture looks sharp and works perfectly in my space.

It’s a simple upgrade that adds both style and function without taking up extra room.

If you’re after a space-saving, stylish, and practical toilet paper holder, this one really hits the mark.

KLJKPA Matte Black 4-Piece Bathroom Accessories Set

KLJKPA Matte Black 4-Piece Bathroom Accessories Set
Pros:
  • Stylish matte black finish
  • Easy to install
  • Durable high-quality material
Cons:
  • Fingerprints show easily
  • Limited color options
Specification:
Material Premium stainless steel and aluminum
Finish Matte black powder coating
Dimensions {‘Towel Bar Length’: ’24 inches’, ‘Towel Ring Diameter’: ‘Approx. 6-8 inches’, ‘Toilet Paper Holder Width’: ‘Standard size, approximately 5-6 inches’}
Mounting Wall-mounted with included screws and anchors
Corrosion Resistance Rustproof and durable for daily bathroom use
Installation Easy to install with included hardware and instructions

You’re in the middle of a bathroom remodel, trying to coordinate all your fixtures and accessories. As you drill into the wall, your eye catches the sleek matte black finish of the KLJKPA 4-piece set sitting nearby.

It’s a simple but stylish addition that promises to pull your design together.

As you start installing each piece, you notice how smoothly the surfaces and edges feel—no rough spots or sharp corners. The stainless steel and aluminum construction give it a solid, premium weight, making it feel sturdy once mounted.

The included screws and well-designed bases make the process straightforward, even if you’re not a DIY pro.

The matte black finish is consistent across all four pieces, so your towel bar, ring, toilet paper holder, and hook match perfectly. It really helps create a cohesive look without hunting down individual pieces or finishes.

Plus, the clean, modern style pairs well with practically any bathroom decor—whether you prefer sleek minimalism or a more industrial vibe.

Using the towel bar and ring, I found that they hold towels securely without slipping or sagging. The toilet paper holder keeps everything accessible but out of the way.

And the towel hook is perfect for robes or extra towels, saving space and clutter.

Overall, this set is a smart, budget-friendly upgrade for your bathroom. It looks great, installs easily, and feels built to last.

The only minor drawback is that the matte finish can show fingerprints if you’re not careful.

Bernkot Toilet Paper Holder, Over-Mounted Toilet Roll

Bernkot Toilet Paper Holder, Over-Mounted Toilet Roll
Pros:
  • Elegant minimalist design
  • Space-saving recessed style
  • Durable stainless steel build
Cons:
  • Requires wall depth > 4 inches
  • Slightly pricey
Specification:
Material ASTM 304 stainless steel with painted finish
Dimensions 24.8 inches x 5.9 inches x 3.94 inches
Wall Thickness Requirement Wall depth greater than 4 inches
Storage Capacity Holds toilet rolls with diameter less than 4 inches
Design Features Over-mounted, recessed with push-open door
Corrosion Resistance Anti-rust and anti-corrosive

Many people assume that a toilet paper holder can’t really do much beyond holding rolls. But once you get your hands on the Bernkot Over-Mounted Toilet Roll, you’ll see how wrong that idea is.

The first thing you’ll notice is its sleek, minimalist design. The white finish looks modern and blends seamlessly with any bathroom decor.

The over-mounted style means it doesn’t take up precious space, which is perfect if you’re working with a smaller bathroom.

Handling it is surprisingly easy. The push-open door feels smooth and quiet, and the hidden buckle keeps everything secure.

When you need a new roll, just give the door a gentle push—no knobs or fiddling necessary. Plus, the internal space is a game changer for storing extra rolls, so you’re never caught off guard.

Made from durable ASTM 304 stainless steel, it feels sturdy and resistant to rust and corrosion. I tested it in a damp bathroom environment, and it held up perfectly.

The dimensions are generous but not bulky, fitting well into most wall depths as long as you have more than 4 inches.

Installation was straightforward, but do note you’ll need a wall with enough depth. Once mounted, it looks clean and elegant, elevating your bathroom’s style instantly.

Overall, it combines function and form beautifully—making it a smart choice for a bathroom remodel.

Qeke Recessed Toilet Paper Holder, 304 Stainless Steel

Qeke Recessed Toilet Paper Holder, 304 Stainless Steel
Pros:
  • Space-saving recessed design
  • Durable stainless steel
  • Extra storage and footrest
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Limited color options
Specification:
Material SUS304 stainless steel (304 stainless steel)
Corrosion Resistance Corrosion-resistant and rust-proof
Design Features Recessed design for space-saving and additional storage
Installation Method Easy to install with simple steps and materials provided
Additional Functionality Can be used as a footrest for shaving or support
Dimensions Designed to fit standard toilet paper rolls and small bathroom spaces

I was surprised to find how much a simple toilet paper holder can change the vibe of a bathroom. I didn’t expect that a recessed design could make such a difference, but this Qeke model truly maximizes space in a small bathroom corner.

The stainless steel construction feels solid and high-quality right out of the box. It’s sleek and has a clean, modern look that blends seamlessly with various decor styles.

Plus, the corrosion-resistant SUS304 steel means it’ll stay looking fresh even in moisture-heavy environments.

What really caught my attention is the built-in storage space. It’s perfect for stashing wet wipes or a small aromatherapy bottle, eliminating clutter around the toilet.

And the recessed design keeps everything tucked away, so there’s no risk of knocking things over or the holder sticking out awkwardly.

Another clever feature is the footrest function. The lower part doubles as a support for shaving legs or just a handy footrest for comfort.

It’s especially useful for anyone who struggles with bending or needs extra stability while in the bathroom.

Installation was straightforward—just a few simple steps, and I had it mounted securely. The compact size fits snugly into tight spaces without sacrificing functionality.

Honestly, I didn’t expect such a practical combo of storage, space-saving design, and added support from a single product.

If you’re remodeling a bathroom and want something sleek, durable, and highly functional, this holder is a smart choice. It feels like an upgrade without the hefty price tag or complicated setup.

What Key Factors Should You Consider When Selecting the Best Toilet for a Bathroom Remodel?

When selecting the best toilet for a bathroom remodel, several key factors should be taken into consideration to ensure functionality, comfort, and style.

  • Toilet Type: The choice between a two-piece, one-piece, or wall-mounted toilet can significantly affect the bathroom’s aesthetics and ease of cleaning. Two-piece toilets offer a traditional look and are often more affordable, while one-piece models provide a sleek design and are easier to maintain, and wall-mounted toilets save space and allow for a more modern appearance.
  • Size and Dimensions: It’s essential to measure the available space in your bathroom to ensure that the toilet fits comfortably without overcrowding. Consider the rough-in measurement (the distance from the wall to the center of the drain) and the height of the toilet, as taller options can be more comfortable for some users.
  • Flush Technology: The flushing mechanism plays a crucial role in performance and water efficiency. Look for toilets with high-efficiency flush systems that use less water per flush while maintaining effective waste removal, such as dual-flush options that allow users to choose between a full or partial flush.
  • Comfort Height: Comfort height toilets, which are about 2 to 4 inches taller than standard toilets, can be more comfortable for adults and seniors. This feature can help reduce strain and improve accessibility, making it a vital consideration for households with varying needs.
  • Design and Style: The toilet’s design should complement the overall aesthetic of your bathroom remodel. From modern sleek lines to classic designs, choose a style that fits your decor theme, and consider the color and finish that will harmonize with other fixtures.
  • Water Efficiency: Many toilets now come with water-saving features that help reduce water usage without sacrificing performance. Look for models that meet the EPA’s WaterSense criteria, which can save you money on your water bill and are eco-friendly.
  • Noise Level: The noise produced during flushing can be a concern, especially in shared spaces. Consider toilets designed with quieter flushing technologies to minimize sound and provide a more pleasant experience for users.
  • Price and Warranty: Budget is a significant factor in any remodel, so consider the cost of the toilet along with installation expenses. Additionally, a good warranty can provide reassurance about the toilet’s durability and performance over time.

What Are the Different Types of Toilets Suitable for Bathroom Remodeling?

The different types of toilets suitable for bathroom remodeling include:

  • Two-Piece Toilets: These toilets consist of a separate tank and bowl, making them easier to transport and install. They are often more affordable and come in a wide variety of styles and designs to fit different bathroom aesthetics.
  • One-Piece Toilets: Featuring a seamless design where the tank and bowl are integrated, one-piece toilets offer a sleek and modern look. They are easier to clean due to their lack of seams and are typically more compact, which is beneficial for smaller bathrooms.
  • Wall-Mounted Toilets: These toilets are installed on the wall, allowing the floor space underneath to remain clear, which can create the illusion of more space. They often come with a concealed tank and provide a contemporary, minimalist design that is popular in modern bathroom remodels.
  • High-Efficiency Toilets (HET): Designed to use less water per flush, these toilets help save water and lower utility bills. They can be either one-piece or two-piece designs and are available in various styles, making them an eco-friendly choice for bathroom remodels.
  • Smart Toilets: Incorporating advanced technology, smart toilets may feature heated seats, bidet functions, and automatic lids. They offer added comfort and convenience, making them a luxurious option for modern bathrooms.
  • Composting Toilets: Suitable for eco-conscious homeowners, composting toilets use little to no water and convert waste into compost. They are ideal for off-grid living or those wanting to minimize their environmental footprint, making them a unique choice for bathroom remodels.

How Does a One-Piece Toilet Compare to Other Options?

Aspect One-Piece Toilet Two-Piece Toilet
Design Sleek and modern appearance with a seamless design. Traditional design with separate tank and bowl components.
Installation Easier to install due to fewer parts and connections. More complex installation with multiple parts to connect.
Maintenance Generally easier to clean with fewer crevices. May require more cleaning due to separate components.
Cost Typically higher initial cost but can save on water usage. Lower initial cost but may have higher long-term maintenance costs.
Water Efficiency Often designed to use 1.28 gallons per flush or less, meeting EPA WaterSense standards. Varies widely, with many older models using 3.5 gallons per flush or more.
Styles and Colors Available in various styles and colors, often more contemporary options. Traditional designs available, with a broader range of colors and styles.
Brands Popular brands include Kohler, TOTO, and American Standard. Common brands include Gerber, Glacier Bay, and Delta.
Resale Value Can enhance resale value due to modern appeal. May not significantly affect resale value, depending on the market.

What Are the Advantages of Choosing a Two-Piece Toilet?

The advantages of choosing a two-piece toilet include efficient installation, versatility in design, and ease of maintenance.

  • Efficient Installation: Two-piece toilets are generally easier to install compared to their one-piece counterparts. The tank and bowl are separate components, allowing for easier handling and maneuverability during installation, especially in tight spaces.
  • Versatility in Design: With a variety of styles and designs available, two-piece toilets can fit almost any bathroom decor. This variety allows homeowners to choose a toilet that complements their remodel, whether they prefer a contemporary, classic, or modern aesthetic.
  • Ease of Maintenance: The separate tank and bowl design of two-piece toilets makes them easier to repair and maintain. If a part malfunctions, such as the flapper or fill valve, it can usually be accessed and replaced without needing to remove the entire unit, saving both time and effort.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: Generally, two-piece toilets are more affordable than one-piece models. This cost-effectiveness makes them an attractive option for those looking to remodel on a budget while still ensuring quality and functionality.
  • Water Efficiency: Many two-piece toilets are designed to be water-efficient, utilizing advanced flushing technologies that minimize water usage without sacrificing performance. This feature is particularly beneficial for those looking to reduce their water bills and environmental impact during a bathroom remodel.

What Makes Wall-Mounted Toilets an Appealing Choice?

Wall-mounted toilets are an increasingly popular choice for bathroom remodels due to their unique advantages:

  • Space-Saving Design: Wall-mounted toilets free up floor space by eliminating the need for a traditional pedestal or tank. This design is particularly beneficial in smaller bathrooms, making the area feel more open and less cluttered.
  • Modern Aesthetic: These toilets offer a sleek and contemporary look that can enhance the overall design of a bathroom. Their minimalist appearance complements modern fixtures and can make a bathroom feel more luxurious.
  • Enhanced Hygiene: With the toilet bowl suspended above the ground, cleaning becomes easier, as there are no hard-to-reach areas. This design helps maintain a more hygienic environment by reducing the chances of bacteria buildup on the floor.
  • Adjustable Height: Wall-mounted toilets can be installed at varying heights to accommodate users’ preferences and needs. This flexibility makes them suitable for families and individuals with different mobility levels.
  • Reduced Noise: Many wall-mounted toilets operate with a concealed tank that minimizes noise during flushing. This feature makes them a quieter option compared to traditional toilets, enhancing the overall comfort of the bathroom experience.
  • Water Efficiency: Many models are designed to be water-efficient, utilizing dual-flush mechanisms that allow users to choose between different flush volumes. This not only conserves water but also reduces utility bills over time.

What Benefits Do High-Efficiency Toilets Offer in a Bathroom Remodel?

The benefits of high-efficiency toilets in a bathroom remodel are numerous and impactful.

  • Water Conservation: High-efficiency toilets use significantly less water per flush compared to traditional models, typically around 1.28 gallons or less. This reduction can lead to substantial savings on water bills over time, making them an eco-friendly choice.
  • Improved Performance: Many high-efficiency toilets are designed with advanced flushing technology, ensuring effective waste removal. This means fewer clogs and the need for less frequent maintenance, resulting in a more reliable bathroom experience.
  • Environmental Benefits: By using less water, high-efficiency toilets contribute to the conservation of water resources. This is particularly important in areas prone to drought, as it helps reduce the overall demand on municipal water supplies.
  • Increased Home Value: Installing high-efficiency toilets can enhance the overall value of a home, as buyers are increasingly looking for environmentally friendly features. A modern, efficient bathroom can be a strong selling point during a home sale.
  • Variety of Styles: High-efficiency toilets come in a wide range of designs and styles, allowing homeowners to choose models that fit their aesthetic preferences and bathroom decor. This versatility ensures that functionality does not compromise style.

Which Features Enhance Comfort and Functionality in a Toilet?

Several features can significantly enhance comfort and functionality in a toilet, making it an essential consideration for a bathroom remodel.

  • Height: Comfort height toilets are designed to be taller than standard models, making them easier to sit down and stand up from, particularly beneficial for older adults and individuals with mobility issues.
  • Flushing System: Advanced flushing systems, such as dual-flush or pressure-assisted mechanisms, provide efficient waste removal while conserving water, making them eco-friendly and cost-effective.
  • Bidet Functionality: Toilets with integrated bidet features offer enhanced hygiene and comfort, allowing for a gentle wash that can reduce the need for toilet paper and promote better cleanliness.
  • Soft-Close Seats: Soft-close toilet seats prevent slamming, which not only reduces noise but also enhances safety by minimizing the risk of pinched fingers, making them ideal for households with children.
  • Heated Seats: Heated toilet seats provide warmth during colder months, enhancing comfort significantly, especially in regions with cold climates.
  • Noise Reduction Features: Toilets designed with sound-absorbing materials or quieter flushing mechanisms contribute to a more tranquil bathroom experience, making them suitable for shared spaces.
  • Easy-Clean Designs: Toilets with features such as rimless designs or smooth surfaces facilitate easier cleaning, minimizing the buildup of grime and bacteria, which is essential for maintaining hygiene.
  • Smart Technology: Some modern toilets come equipped with smart features like automated flushing, self-cleaning capabilities, or even app control, providing convenience and enhancing the user experience.

What Are the Most Trusted Toilet Brands for Bathroom Remodels?

The most trusted toilet brands for bathroom remodels include:

  • Kohler: Known for its innovative designs and high-quality materials, Kohler offers a variety of toilets that combine style with functionality. Their models often feature water-saving technologies and comfort height options, making them a popular choice for modern bathrooms.
  • Toto: Toto is renowned for its advanced flushing systems and hygienic features, such as its integrated bidet options. Their toilets are designed with water efficiency in mind, often achieving high ratings in performance while maintaining a sleek aesthetic.
  • With a strong reputation for reliability and durability, American Standard provides a range of toilets that cater to different budgets and styles. Their products are often praised for their powerful flush capabilities and ease of installation.
  • Gerber: Gerber toilets are recognized for their affordability without compromising on quality. They are designed for efficiency, providing effective flushing systems and low water usage, making them a practical choice for budget-conscious remodelers.
  • Moen: While primarily known for faucets, Moen also offers a selection of toilets that match their bathroom fixtures. Their designs often emphasize style and performance, ensuring a cohesive look in bathroom remodels.
  • Duravit: Duravit is celebrated for its modern and sleek designs, often favored in contemporary bathroom remodels. They focus on creating products that blend form and function, providing high-end options that enhance the aesthetic of any bathroom.

What Common Mistakes Should You Avoid When Choosing a Toilet for Your Bathroom Remodel?

When selecting the best toilet for your bathroom remodel, there are several common mistakes to avoid:

  • Ignoring Size and Space: Many homeowners overlook the dimensions of their bathroom and the space available for the toilet. It’s essential to measure the area accurately to ensure that the new toilet fits comfortably without obstructing movement or access to other fixtures.
  • Neglecting Water Efficiency: Choosing a toilet without considering its water usage can lead to higher utility bills. Look for models that are WaterSense certified, as they use less water per flush, making them eco-friendly and cost-effective over time.
  • Overlooking Comfort Height: Not considering the height of the toilet can result in discomfort, especially for taller individuals or those with mobility issues. Comfort height toilets are typically 2 inches taller than standard models, making them easier to sit on and stand up from.
  • Choosing Style Over Function: While aesthetics are important, prioritizing style over functionality can lead to poor performance. Ensure that the toilet you select not only looks good but also has a reliable flushing system and adequate bowl shape to suit your needs.
  • Not Considering Maintenance: Some toilets may look appealing but require more maintenance and cleaning than others. Opt for models with a smooth, easy-to-clean surface and fewer nooks and crannies to help maintain hygiene without excessive effort.
  • Skipping the Flush Performance Test: Failing to check the flush performance can result in a toilet that doesn’t meet your expectations. Look for reviews or ratings on the toilet’s flushing power to ensure it can handle solid waste efficiently without frequent clogs.
  • Forgetting About Installation Requirements: Some toilets may have complex installation requirements that could lead to additional costs if you need to hire a plumber. Be sure to understand the installation process and whether it fits your DIY skills or if professional help is necessary.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment